Officials questioned the man about the curriculum and specialized subjects, and after receiving “unsatisfactory” answers, they assigned him as an anti-aircraft gunner to an assault battalion. The Transcarpathian District Administrative Court ruled that the military registration and enlistment office had exceeded its authority and ordered that the student be removed from the military unit’s roster.
A high-profile legal precedent was considered in Transcarpathia: The Transcarpathian District Administrative Court ruled that the mobilization of a 50-year-old vocational college student—who, at the time of conscription, had a valid official deferment confirmed in the state “Reserve+” app—was unlawful and annulled it. Officials from the Territorial Center for Recruitment and Social Support (TCRS) decided to draft the man into the military because they doubted the authenticity of his studies following an “exam” conducted on site.
The circumstances of the case and the court’s verdict are detailed in the materials of court case No. 260/5321/26 of the Transcarpathian District Administrative Court.
From a document check in Mukachevo to an assault battalion in a single day
As established during the court hearing, the events unfolded in the following chronological order:
- Legal deferment for full-time study: The man, born in 1976, was enrolled in a full-time program at the Svalyava Technical Vocational College, majoring in “Tourism and Recreation.” Information about his current deferment from conscription during mobilization was officially entered into the registry and displayed in the “Reserve+” mobile app, valid until August 1, 2026;
- An impromptu “knowledge test” at the Technical College: On July 18, police officers stopped the man in the city of Mukachevo and took him to the Technical College. During the conversation, representatives of the military registration and enlistment office conducted an oral examination of the student regarding his academic program. According to officials, the 50-year-old student was unable to name his major’s core courses, explain the structure of the curriculum, or describe the exam schedule;
- Conscription Despite Registration Status: Suspecting that enrollment in college was merely a formality to avoid mobilization, TCC staff decided to draft the man that same day. After passing the military medical examination, he was enlisted in the military unit’s personnel roster as an anti-aircraft gunner in an assault battalion.
The Court’s Position: The Military Registration and Enlistment Office Has No Right to Examine Students
After reviewing the materials of the administrative lawsuit, the court fully sided with the mobilized student and clearly pointed out a gross abuse of authority on the part of the TCC officials:
- Subjective doubts are not grounds for conscription: personal assumptions or doubts held by military registration and enlistment office staff regarding a student’s level of knowledge do not grant them any legal right to disregard a valid deferment from mobilization;
- Monitoring academic performance is the exclusive authority of the college: only the administration of the educational institution—not military authorities—has the right to verify a student’s class attendance, level of knowledge, and academic performance;
- Legal validity of “Reserve+”: The information contained in the electronic military registration document (“Reserve+”) has the same legal force as paper documents, and the TCC has no right to unilaterally revoke a valid deferment without a corresponding collegial decision by the commission.
The Court’s Ruling
The Transcarpathian District Administrative Court ruled:
- to declare unlawful the actions regarding the conscription of the man into military service during mobilization;
- to revoke the order of the head of the Military Registration and Enlistment Office regarding conscription and the order of the military unit commander regarding the plaintiff’s enrollment in the personnel roster;
- to order the military unit to remove the man from the personnel roster and discharge him from service.
However, the decision of the court of first instance has not yet become final—the Territorial Military Commissariat and the military unit have 30 days to file an appeal.
Source: Case file No. 260/5321/26 of the Transcarpathian District Administrative Court.









